Menu
When we hear the term ‘stoic’, the image that perhaps jumps to the mind is that of a hardened, emotionless individual, steeled against any personal distress, immune to tears, to the point of seeming robotic. This perception, rooted in stereotypes and misconceptions, has clouded the holistic understanding of stoicism. The notion that a stoic is impervious to emotional pain, and thus, refrains from crying, is far from the reality. Stoicism is not about achieving a state of emotional sterility – it is about forging a rational approach to navigate the crafts of life. Stoics do, indeed, feel; they do, indeed, grieve, and they do, certainly, cry. To comprehend this, we must first delve into the essence of stoicism.
Stoicism is an ancient philosophical school, developed by Zeno of Citium, propounding the doctrine of ethics as the main pillar of wisdom. Sages such as Seneca, Epictetus, and the great emperor Marcus Aurelius, further enriched the base set by Zeno. At its core, stoicism teaches the cultivation of virtue – wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance – which enables us to perceive the world without the goggles of biases and prejudices. It encourages us to distinguish between what we can control (our actions, words, thoughts, attitudes) and what we can’t (everything external). This degree of rational comprehension and acceptance enable the stoics to maintain tranquility and serenity amidst the tumultuous swings of life. However, this stoic tranquility should not be mistaken for indifference or apathy. Stoicism does not demand an emotional veto – it recommends emotional intelligence.
The emotional intelligence of a stoic arises from their understanding that emotions are natural, unavoidable constructs, triggered by our perception of our circumstances. Stoics don’t suppress emotions – they analyze them. They understand the cause, the effect, and the consequential response the emotion invokes. They know that the underlying perception that sparked the emotion can be controlled, indirectly controlling the emotional reaction. Stoicism does not promote desensitivity; it promotes dispassion—one governs the emotions and doesn’t get governed by them.
Stoicism is engaged deeply with emotion theory. It offers a unique, practical perspective on dealing with emotions which invites reinterpretation and not rejection. According to stoicism, emotions or ‘passions’ are judgements or beliefs which we form about the things and events around us. Some of these emotions are ‘negative’ – such as distress, fear, lust, and delight which arise from false beliefs. While others, termed as ‘eupatheiai’, meaning ‘good feelings’, spring from correct judgments and are desired by stoics.
Stoics emphasized that negative emotions result from mistaken beliefs about the goodness or badness of externals. They are experiences of excessive impulses, disruptive to rationality and tranquility. For instance, crying out of fear or distress, signifies a mistaken belief that something terrible has happened which is not the case as per stoic worldview.
In contrast, good emotions are associated with wisdom, depicting rational responses to situations and events. They include feelings such as wish (instead of lust), caution (instead of fear), and joy (instead of delight) which stem from understanding the world, and oneself, from an unbiased, detached perspective. Stoics recognize that crying can harmonize with wisdom. It can be a natural response to certain situations and events, and not necessarily indicative of a lapse in judgment.
Thus, drawing from the stoic perception of emotions and rational understanding, one can infer that a stoic may cry, provided the tears are not born of negative emotion or irrationality. But this is an overview, a shallow dive into the ocean of stoicism. The depths are darker, deeper, and more enlightening.
The craft of balancing emotional awareness with non-attachment or indifference is a key facet of Stoic philosophy. Stoicism does not propose an unemotional or indifferent approach to life. Instead, it implores us to exercise rational judgment in dealing with our emotional instincts. The Stoic sage, armed with the tools of logic and wisdom, enters the arena of life not as an indifferent spectator but as an engaged player, albeit one who remains unswayed by the illusory attractions of externalities.
By maintaining a clear line of distinction between domains of control and those beyond it, Stoics mastered the art of managing their emotional responses. This does not equate to emotional muteness or insensibility, but rather the practice of modulating emotional reactions judiciously and proportionately. Do not misconstrue this as emotional apathy or indifference; it’s about being present, mentally engaged and yet not overwhelmed or controlled by emotions. Understanding this is a vital step towards resolving the question – Can Stoics Cry? Let us delve deeper into that in the subsequent section.
The crux of our discourse lies herein – can stoics cry? Can a philosophy that values rationality over emotion, wisdom over folly, and self-control over self-indulgence, comprehend, much less approve, the shedding of tears? The answer finds root in the philosophical underpinnings of stoicism itself.
As we have emphasized, stoicism does not advocate emotional suppression. Instead, it endorses emotional intelligence – the ability to identify, understand, and manage our emotions. Crying, a profound emotional response and an integral part of human emotional expression, should not be viewed as an antithesis to stoicism. Stoicism assuages the mind with wisdom, illuminating that tears born from sound judgment are neither irrational nor reprehensible.
Stoics can cry, and they do. However, the philosophy insists that the cause for the tears – be it joy, sorrow, anger, fear, or empathy – must mirror reality and be rationally justifiable. They can cry when circumstances warrant an emotional response, but without losing their serene acceptance of reality. Crying must remain within the bounds of rationality, not as an outburst of uncontrolled emotional chaos, but as a considered response to the situation at hand.
Exploring further into the realm of emotive expression and its intersection with stoic philosophy, let’s set our focus on the phenomenon of emotional release, particularly through the act of crying. The act of crying is viewed by many as a cathartic release of pent-up emotions, a biological response that serves to cleanse the mind and momentarily unburden the heart.
Going against the grain of the popular stereotype, stoicism does not categorically dismiss the act of crying and the associated emotional release. Stoicism, contrary to common understanding, is not about pursuing a sense of stoic detachment. Instead, it’s about engaging with our emotions, understanding them, and managing them. Achieving this understanding can allow for the release of emotions, including through tears, while still upholding stoic principles.
To put simply, stoicism does not deny crying as a form of emotional release. However, it does maintain a caveat. Crying, in the view of stoicism, can be a form of rational emotional expression when performed with a clear comprehension of the causative reason and with conscious control. Unhinged, irrational crying emerging from false perceptions and uncontrolled passions does not fit into the stoic frame of philosophy. However, a stoic sage upon comprehending the situation might even perceive the act of crying as a useful physiological response designed by nature to deal with intense emotions.
Commencing complex discussions, like this explication of Stoicism’s perception of crying, warrants an exploration of the misconceptions that linger around this topic. It is greatly misunderstood that Stoicism flatly disapproves of expressing emotion, especially through tears. However, this misconstrued image contradicts the ethos of Stoic philosophy.
Many assume that being a ‘Stoic’ equates to being emotionless, void of any emotional reaction or expression. This misconception roots itself in a deficient understanding of Stoicism. Stoics are indeed trained to keep their emotions in check, but they are by no means devoid of emotions. Stoics experience the full range of human emotions but with a twist – they exercise control and rationality over their emotions.
Another common misunderstanding is associating crying with a lack of self-possession, equated to a failure of Stoic principles. Again the core Stoicism principle of responding to events with wisdom and self-control is misunderstood. Crying, as Stoics understand it, is a rational response to certain situations, not an indication of weakness or lack of self-control.
Often Stoicism and emotional indifference are considered synonymous; however, the notion is misplaced. Stoics, in fact, promote active engagement with emotions, understanding them, and harnessing intelligence to respond rationally. Stoics are not stone-hearted; rather, their philosophy champions the notion of conscious emotional management.
Moving away from misconceptions, we direct our focus towards understanding Stoicism’s techniques, primarily mindfulness, fostering emotional health. Stoicism’s stance on mindfulness lays the groundwork for emotional intelligence, resilience, and emotional health, intimately connected to the expression of tears.
Stoic mindfulness encourages living ‘in the present’ and avoiding disruptive thoughts about the past or the future. It fosters a sense of calm and emotional balance, fostering greater emotional well-being. During emotional highs and lows, practicing mindfulness can anchor us in the present, offering a sound platform for managing emotions, including crying.
Stoicism promotes the construct of emotional resilience – the ability to bounce back from emotional setbacks. By focusing on factors within our control and staying indifferent to external influences, Stoics build a strong coping mechanism. This grants the freedom to rationally experience and express emotions, including through tears, without spiralling into emotional disruption.
Stoicism greatly contributes to emotional health, advocating for rationality, acceptance, and measured emotional responses. Consequently, Stoicism does not view the act of crying negatively; on the contrary, it sees crying as a sign of being in touch with one’s emotions and processing those emotions. Frequently, the ability to shed tears is a key indicator of robust emotional health endorsed in Stoic philosophy
To further strengthen the connection between Stoicism and crying, it proves beneficial to assess real-life instances. These examples, drawn from various contexts, emerge as concrete evidence that Stoics, anchored in their philosophy, did shed tears.
Epictetus, a well-respected Stoic philosopher, often counseled his disciples about their ‘sphere of control’ and how understanding it could lead to emotional liberation. He communicated that in cases of tragic circumstances that fall out of their control, like the death of a loved one, it was human, natural, and rational to grieve and cry, emphasizing that it does not contradict Stoic principles.
The Roman Stoic Seneca offers another compelling example. Seneca spoke about rational affection – the balance between being attached to loved ones without being overwhelmed by debilitating emotions. He acknowledged that events like the death of a loved one could trigger an emotional reaction including tears, affirming that such instances did not betray Stoic principles given they were kept within the rationality bounds.
Fast forward to the contemporary world, countless individuals practice Stoicism and aren’t shy about shedding tears. This acknowledgement further cements the Stoic philosophy’s stance of crying being entirely rational, under the right circumstances, and certainly not contradictory to maintaining emotional balance and resilience.
Before we can truly delve into the depths of the stoic approach to crying, we must first navigate through the misty realms of misconceptions saturating the understanding of Stoicism and, indeed, crying. The most common among these are the notions that Stoics are emotionless, that crying indicates a lack of stoic self-control, and that Stoics are unresponsive to emotions. Remember, many of these misconceptions likely arise from a lacking understanding of true Stoicism.
This misunderstanding is perhaps the most pervasive. In truth, Stoics do not void emotions. Instead, they seek to maintain rationality when faced with emotional circumstances. Stoics aspire to respond to emotions with wisdom and balance, embracing the feelings while detaching themselves from the unruly emotional turmoil.
This misconception is equally unfounded. To the Stoic, crying does not represent a loss of control, but rather a manifestation of an emotion. If this emotional expression springs from a place of rational understanding and is a proportionate response to the situation at hand, it aligns perfectly with Stoic principles.
Many mistakenly assume that Stoicism and emotional indifference are interchangeable. However, true Stoicism promotes active engagement with, and understanding of, our emotions. Far from advocating for emotional indifference, Stoic principles encourage a wise and considered response to our feelings. Just as important: Stoics are not stone-hearted. The Stoic is both responsive and empathetic, possessing the capacity for compassion and understanding.
Having clarified common misconceptions about Stoic philosophy, it is now appropriate to introduce its techniques that support emotional health. Among these, Stoic mindfulness is paramount. ‘Mindfulness’ in Stoicism acts as a form of mental training, requiring us to be present in the moment, free from distractions, centered, and aware.
Generally, the aim is to inhibit the automatic recourse to ‘default mode’, or passive state of mind, instead promoting active and attentive mental states. This, in turn, enables us to stay rooted in the present moment, curbing disruptive thoughts about the past or the unpredictable future. As such, during emotionally heightened times, practising mindfulness provides an anchor that allows us to regulate our emotions effectively and rationally.
Stoic philosophy strongly promotes the concept of emotional resilience. This is the ability to withstand or recover quickly from challenging conditions or emotional setbacks. The emphasis on controlling our responses and maintaining indifference to external influences builds a solid mechanism for handling stress. Emotional resilience serves as a Stoic’s shield, allowing for the rational experience and expression of emotions, including through tears, without falling into emotional turbulence.
Stoic philosophy makes substantial contributions to promoting emotional health. By advocating for the acceptance and measured response to emotions, Stoicism fosters an environment conducive to emotional wellbeing. Thus, in stark contrast to common misperceptions, Stoicism does not view crying negatively. Conversely, it recognizes the act of crying as an indicator of being attuned to one’s emotions and healthily processing those emotions. As a result, Stoicism acknowledges the ability to shed tears as a crucial attribute of sound emotional health.
Let us now turn to real-life examples where notable Stoics have shed tears. This concrete evidence points to the fact that Stoics, grounded in their philosophical beliefs, can indeed cry. Let us examine these historical instances to further strengthen the connection between Stoicism and crying.
Epictetus, an esteemed Stoic philosopher, often guided his followers’ understanding of their ‘sphere of control’ and how recognizing these boundaries could lead to emotional liberation. He asserted that in situations beyond one’s control, such as the death of a loved one, it was perfectly natural to grieve and to cry. He emphasized that this emotional response did not counter the principles of Stoicism. The proviso was that the tears should not be an expression of feeling victimized by the external event, but of acknowledging the significance of the loss.
The Roman Stoic, Seneca, also illustrated the Stoic position on crying. In his work ‘Of Consolation: To Marcia’, he considers the death of a loved one. Contrasting ‘grief’ and ‘duty’, he argued that a Stoic could experience the pain of loss and shed tears, but should not wallow in self-pity and excessive grief. Thus, a Stoic can rationally experience and express sadness, even through tears, without violating Stoic principles.
Navigating to the contemporary era, numerous individuals are exploring Stoic philosophy as a guide to managing the complexities of modern life. They too, acknowledge their emotions and need for the occasional catharsis, including through tears. They understand that crying, when rationally expressive and controlled, aligns with Stoic philosophy and does not undermine their emotional resilience.
Discover gifts that inspire, motivate, and celebrate with Stoic Quotes from Pure Stoic. Find unique and meaningful presents for everyone on your list.
